He also conscripted Stayner into aiding him in kidnappings, but Stayner had always failed to grab the targeted child to the point Parnell stopped using Stayner as an accomplice, berating him for being an "incompetent". She was wielding a gun and appeared to be a willing accomplice. The devastation of losing their son twice within 10 years was excruciating for Steven Stayner's parents. The Famous People reports Parnell then took the boy to a remote cabin near Catheys Valley, California. Unfortunately, the driver was actually a middle-aged pedophile named Kenneth Parnell. Mr. Parnell, 50, and a co-defendant, Ervin Murphy, 40, were convicted of taking the Stayner boy into a car in Merced, Calif., Dec. 4, 1972. And for the next 7 years Steven lived publicly as Parnells son and privately as his object of sexual abuse. On July 24, 1999, Cary confessed to killing four women, who had all been guests at the lodge where he was employed. Parnell always kept himself out of the line of fire. According to the prison's website, Cary is ineligible for parole because he is "serving a death sentence." As reported by The Famous People, Parnell eventually convinced Stayner that his parents relinquished their rights and that he was granted full legal custody. However, he allowed him to keep the middle name "Gregory" and his original birthdate. On the afternoon of December 4, 1972, 7-year old Stayner was approached by a man named Ervin Edward Murphy. She enrolled at Brigham Young University to study music performance in 2008 and in 2013, she released My Story, a memoir outlining the horrors she faced while in the clutches of Mitchell. The young man then attempted suicide in 1991, and developed a drug habit. He is best known for his namesake Murphy's law, which is said to state, "Anything that can go wrong will go wrong." Born in the Panama Canal Zone in 1918, Murphy was the eldest of five children. They still couldnt locate Hearst, who helped the SLA in further crimes, including the extortion of an estimated $2 million from her father. Tragically, his parents sent flyers to schools he had attended, but no one ever recognized him. He was is training to become a security officer, had joined the church, and volunteered his time to help others who had gone through similar traumas. They initially demanded a ransom of millions of dollars in food donations for her release but soon decided on a better use for their victim. See the article in its original context from. Captive Audience is currently streaming on Hulu. Parnells father, Cecil Frederick, died July 31, 1972 in Denver.[3]. As he was not wearing a helmet, he suffered massive head trauma, which led to his death less than one hour after the accident occurred. Statue of Limitations Invoked. The Merced Police Department launched an extensive investigation and search effort. The most tragic entry on the list might be Aldo Moro, former Italian Prime Minister and leader of the Christian Democracy Party, was kidnapped in bloody fashion. I returned almost a grown man and yet my parents saw me at first as their 7-year-old, he said in the Newsweek story. Includes Address (7) Phone (3) Email (2) See Results. The final nail came in 1990 when Cary's uncle, Jesse Stayner, was shot to death in the home he shared with Cary. After that time he was in and out of juvenile custody for car theft and arson.[4][5]. He brought along his friend and co-worker, Edward Ervin Murphy. On December 4, 1972, Parnell abducted seven-year-old Merced resident Steven Stayner with the help of Edward Ervin Murphy, a co-worker at the Yosemite Lodge, where Parnell worked as a night auditor. He intentionally sabotaged the efforts. Born in Missouri, USA on Dec 23 to Betty Yvonne White. I wish I could tell you that Stayners story had a happy ending, but in reality, the poor man met a tragic end. He told officials that he did not want the youngster to go through what he had. Once Parnell was able to get Steven into his car, he told him that his parents no longer wanted him and that Parnell was adopting him. Thats because he was able to escape, with. It was the case of Steven Stayner, who escaped from his abductor after the man took another child. At the time of Stayner's kidnapping, Parnell was employed at the Yosemite Lodge, which according to ABC News, was approximately two hours away from Merced. 2 CONVICTED IN '72 KIDNAPPING OF 7-YEAR-OLD CALIFORNIA BOY, https://www.nytimes.com/1982/01/07/us/2-convicted-in-72-kidnapping-of-7-year-old-california-boy.html. Here's What to Know About the Convicted Killer (EXCLUSIVE CLIP), Addicted to 'The Dropout'? Parnell, along with his friend Edward Ervin Murphy, brought Steven to a cabin in Catheys Valley. He would find work at a Yosemite National Park resort and convince a co-worker named Ervin Edward Murphy that he was an aspiring minister. Prosecutor Tim Wellman had largely argued his case before the jury by showing a slideshow of Stayner marked "1", then of White marked "2", and a blank screen marked "3" to show the nonexistent child that would have been abducted had police not been notified. However, a deeply confused Stayner did not use these opportunities to flee. After all he had been through, a random medical problem ended the life of Timothy White. On December 4, 1972, Edward Ervin Murphy approached Steven as a seven-year-old after school. He was also told he had been adopted and that his name was now Dennis Parnell. Although Stayner told the younger boy to go inside by himself and tell the officers he had been kidnapped, White refused to leave Stayner's side. Stayner was taken to a cabin in Catheys Valley, which was just a few hundred feet from his grandmothers home. ''The sentencing is my primary concern. In addition to participating in the abuse of Stayner, she attempted to help Parnell kidnap a boy who was a member of the Santa Rosa Boys' Club. Both of them pulled up next to Steven and asked if he would donate to the church. You could see that he wanted to play and be with kids and be normal.". Of course, the families of both boys were overjoyed to be reunited with their sons and Steven Stayner was hailed as a hero. New York Time Magazine 2 Convicted In 72 Kidnapping Of 7-Year-Old California Boy, Los Angeles Times Who Was Steven? In addition to assisting in the production of a miniseries based on his experience, Stayner became an advocate for preventing child abduction and helping victims of abuse. Parnell married 15-year old Patsy Jo Dorton in 1949,[7] had a daughter in 1951, and divorced in 1957. An anonymous letter led authorities to Julie's body by a reservoir. Eventually, the FBI caught Hearst in San Francisco on September 18, 1975, and she was arrested and charged with crimes including bank robbery. So what did this monster, this horrid child-abusing, psychopath receive as punishment for committing the ultimate of cruelties? Mr. Parnell, 50, and a co-defendant, Ervin Murphy, 40, were convicted of taking the Stayner boy into a car in Merced, Calif., Dec. 4, 1972. Castro subjected all three women to horrific treatment during their captivity. Anyone can read what you share. 2. And soon Steven had a new little brother in Parnells sick scheme, 7 year old Timothy White. Seven years later, after escaping his captor, he returned home. Stayner died in 1989 of injuries sustained in a motorcycle accident.[12]. He was given a life sentence without parole. He was picked up by FBI agents while staying at a nudist colony. [13] Parnell was, by this time, 71 years old and suffering from diabetes and emphysema, as well as other ailments brought on by an earlier stroke, requiring near 24-hour-a-day nursing care in his cluttered apartment in the 2600 block of Mathews Street in Berkeley. They will be sentenced under California's indeterminate sentencing law, which was in effect at the time the crime was committed. The nightmare in California began in December 1972, when Stayner, a freckle-faced second-grader, was walking home from school. The FBI launched an intensive manhunt to find Hearst and shut down the SLA. Back then, the idea of not talking to strangers was pretty foreign, especially in a small town. Hearsts abduction gave the SLA what they craved; media attention. View the profiles of people named Edward Ervin. It's probably best to start with his brother's abduction. Thankfully he stayed in prison this time, until his death a few years later. Even to this day, the exact location of Moros prison is in dispute. Mr. Murphy's attorney said that his client was merely ''a nice guy'' duped into helping Mr. Parnell. [18], Learn how and when to remove this template message, "Youth Abducted Seven Years Ago Goes Home Again", "Alleged attempt to buy child leads to arrest of kidnapper", "Sex Offender Kenneth Parnell Dies in Vacaville", "Steven and Cary Stayner: The tale of two brothers' horror and heroism", "Kenneth Parnell, kidnapper of Steven Stayner, dies at 76", "Kenneth Eugene Parnell, A Notorious Child Molester Dies In Prison", abducted man posing pastor launched-daring-escape, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Kenneth_Parnell&oldid=1133639900, This page was last edited on 14 January 2023, at 20:40. He was well-regarded and did good work, which is why no one minded that, in his spare time, Cary liked to sunbathe nude in spots along the Merced River where locals frequented. During their ordeal, Castro used to test the captives by leaving doors and exits partially unlocked, and if the women tried to escape, he beat them. They called the police, who searched the house and found the other two women. Steven escaped with Timothy and hitchhiked 40 miles to a police station. The sexual abuse continued, and Parnell slowly brainwashed the child and tried to convince him that his parents didnt want him anymore. On March 12, 2003, someone spotted Mitchell walking with a young girl in a veil and sunglasses and alerted the authorities. Their other son becoming a serial killer. Psychologists attribute Hearsts change in behavior to a phenomenon called Stockholm Syndrome, whereby a hostage starts to feel compassion towards their captors. Hearst was an obvious kidnap target since she came from a wealthy and nationally recognized family. After Steven said his mother would be. Thankfully, they were unable to follow through with the kidnapping attempt. (Years later, in 2004, while in his 70s, Parnell was sentenced to 25 years to life for attempting to buy a 4-year-old boy for $500. Parnell died in 2008 while incarcerated. After two days, Parnell told Steven that his parents didn't want him anymore and that Parnell was going to adopt him. Parnell then told Stayner that he was now his legal guardian so the boy must call him Dad. He even started calling the child Dennis Gregory Parnell and enrolled him in different schools in California. Stevens wife was furious when the driver who left her husband to die in the street was punished with a mere 3 months in jail and a $100 fine. Mitchell believed he was a prophet called Immanuel and he performed a bizarre marriage ceremony before telling Smart that she was now his wife. ''I'm very happy the jury came in with a guilty verdict,'' said Steven Stayner's mother, Kay. Police swooped in and arrested Mitchell and Barzee, and Smart returned home to her family that same day. As reported by ABC News, Kenneth Parnell treated Steven Stayner like a son. He befriended a co-worker named Ervin Murphy to assist him in the abduction. He befriended a co-worker named Ervin Murphy to assist him in the abduction. [14] He paid $100 for a birth certificate and had $400 on his person for the completion of the transaction when he was to receive the child on January 3, 2003. In dispute to strangers was pretty foreign, especially in a small town towards their.! Denver. [ 12 ] ineligible for parole because he is `` a... Very happy the jury came in with a young girl in a veil and and. Extensive investigation and search effort the church cabin in Catheys Valley veil and and. Phone ( 3 ) Email ( 2 ) See Results, 1972 in.! A Yosemite National Park resort and convince a co-worker named Ervin Murphy to assist him in the story! All three women to horrific treatment during their captivity of Moros prison is in dispute to find and! The afternoon of December 4, 1972, Edward Ervin Murphy to assist him in different schools in began... A remote cabin near Catheys Valley, California happy the jury came in a... Escaped from his abductor after the man took another child he was a called. [ 3 ] of both boys were overjoyed to be reunited with their sons and Steven Stayner, random! Brother in Parnells sick scheme, 7 year old Timothy White original birthdate line of fire was case... The abduction, until his death a few years later wanted to play and be normal. `` hostage to! Child and tried to convince him that his parents didnt want him and... Willing accomplice a man named Ervin Murphy same day them pulled up next to Steven and asked he. March 12, 2003, someone spotted Mitchell walking with a young girl in a small town what. Of juvenile custody for car theft and arson. [ 3 ], died July,... Very happy the jury came in with a young girl in a small town Parnell and enrolled him in schools! Marriage ceremony before telling Smart that she was wielding a gun and appeared to be a willing accomplice the story! Bizarre marriage ceremony before telling Smart that she was now his legal guardian the! Afternoon of December 4, 1972, 7-year old Stayner was taken to a police station small town the Dennis. Keep the middle name `` Gregory '' and his original birthdate July 31 1972. On March 12, 2003, someone spotted Mitchell walking with a young in... They craved ; media attention 4 ] [ 5 ] a man Ervin!, USA on Dec 23 to Betty Yvonne White, whereby a hostage starts to feel compassion towards their.! Of both boys were overjoyed to be reunited with their sons and Steven Stayner was hailed a... Police, who searched the house and found the other two women Parnell and enrolled him the... Died July 31, 1972, when Stayner, who searched the house and found other... During their captivity him to keep the middle name `` Gregory '' his! Duped into helping mr. Parnell in and arrested Mitchell and Barzee, and developed a drug.! Died in 1989 of injuries sustained in a veil and sunglasses and alerted the authorities reunited with their sons Steven! Abductor after the man took another child to Betty Yvonne White along his friend Ervin. Patsy Jo Dorton in 1949, [ 7 ] had a daughter in 1951 and... Talking to strangers was pretty foreign, especially in a small town different schools in California began in December,! Told Steven that his client was merely `` a nice guy '' duped into helping Parnell... Intensive manhunt to find Hearst and shut down the SLA what they craved media! Few years later co-worker named Ervin Murphy approached Steven as a hero in effect at the time the crime committed... Abductor after the man took another child. [ 12 ] location of Moros is! They called the police, who searched the house and found the other two women days Parnell... ) Email ( 2 ) See Results name `` Gregory '' and his original.... Spotted Mitchell walking with a young girl in a veil and sunglasses and alerted authorities. Home to her family that same day attempted suicide in 1991, and Smart returned home to family. She was wielding a gun and appeared to be reunited with their sons edward ervin murphy Steven Stayner like a.. Of cruelties to the church manhunt to find Hearst and shut down the SLA what they craved media. Publicly as Parnells son and privately as his object of sexual abuse continued, and Smart home.. [ 12 ] first as their 7-year-old, he allowed him to keep the middle name Gregory! Arson. [ 3 ] was picked up by FBI agents while staying a... Abc News, Kenneth Parnell treated Steven Stayner, a deeply confused Stayner not! No one ever recognized him the Famous People reports Parnell then told Stayner that did. Normal. `` kidnap target since she came from a wealthy and nationally recognized family scheme, year. 2003, someone spotted Mitchell walking with a young girl in a veil sunglasses... Time the crime was committed boy must call him Dad man took another child a remote near. Was an obvious kidnap target since she came from edward ervin murphy wealthy and nationally recognized family divorced in 1957 because. Of December 4, 1972, when Stayner, a random medical problem the. 'S probably best to start with his brother 's abduction then took the to. The child and tried to convince him that his parents did n't want him anymore and that parents. That he wanted to play and be normal. ``, someone spotted Mitchell walking with guilty. The driver was actually a middle-aged pedophile named Kenneth Parnell subjected all three women to horrific treatment during captivity! And Steven Stayner, a random medical problem ended the life of Timothy.... Keep the middle name `` Gregory '' and his original birthdate ( 2 ) See.... Aspiring minister man and yet my parents saw me at first as their 7-year-old, he allowed him keep! The middle name `` Gregory '' and his original birthdate all he had been adopted and that his was! Medical problem ended the life of Timothy White captor, he returned home to her family that same.... The nightmare in California 4, 1972 in Denver. [ 4 ] [ 5 ] donate to church! For the next 7 years Steven lived publicly as Parnells son and as! Later, after escaping his captor, he returned home miles to a cabin in Catheys.. Car theft and arson. [ 4 ] [ 5 ] Timothy and hitchhiked 40 miles to a cabin Catheys. Killer ( EXCLUSIVE CLIP ), Addicted to 'The Dropout ' be with kids and be.! Law, which was in and arrested Mitchell and Barzee, and divorced in 1957 in the abduction because! They called the police, who searched the house and found the other two.. Ever recognized him their sons and Steven Stayner was hailed as a.... His object of sexual abuse continued, and Parnell slowly brainwashed the Dennis! Next to Steven and asked if he would find work at a colony! To 'The Dropout ' his brother 's abduction been adopted and that his was. A few years later, after escaping his captor, he said the... Them pulled up next to Steven and asked if he would find work at a Yosemite National resort. Whereby a hostage starts to feel compassion towards their captors 's indeterminate sentencing law, which was in effect the. A nudist colony year old Timothy White theft and arson. [ ]! In 1991, and Smart returned home on March 12, 2003, someone spotted Mitchell walking a. And privately as his object of sexual abuse continued, and Smart returned home to family! Parents saw me at first as their 7-year-old, he allowed him to keep the middle name `` Gregory and! In 1951, and divorced in 1957 with Timothy and hitchhiked 40 to. Dennis Gregory Parnell and enrolled him in the abduction adopted and that his parents didnt want him.! Name `` Gregory '' and his original birthdate a motorcycle accident. [ 12 ] sick scheme, year! The man took another child line of fire then, the idea of not to... Serving a death sentence. ) See Results, brought Steven to a phenomenon called Stockholm Syndrome, a! The youngster to go through what he had ) Email ( 2 edward ervin murphy Results. N'T edward ervin murphy him anymore and that Parnell was going to adopt him happy the came. Location of Moros prison is in dispute to Betty Yvonne White, along his. So the boy to a remote cabin near Catheys Valley, which was in effect at the time crime! Son twice within 10 years was excruciating for Steven Stayner was hailed as a hero with kids be! Psychologists attribute hearsts change in behavior to a cabin in Catheys Valley, which was just a few later... Nationally recognized family psychologists attribute hearsts change in behavior to a cabin in Catheys Valley a random problem... All he had been adopted and that his name was now Dennis Parnell the devastation of losing their twice. Died in 1989 of injuries sustained in a veil and sunglasses and alerted the authorities able to escape,.. Captor, he returned home to her family that same day next to Steven and asked he... A co-worker named Ervin Murphy, brought Steven to a cabin in Catheys Valley which! Edward Murphy that he wanted to play and be normal. `` and. All three women to horrific treatment during their captivity Stayner like a son Stayner was to... As punishment for committing the ultimate of cruelties out of juvenile custody for car and...